Power Resigns as RI BHDDH Director

By Gina Macris

A. Kathryn Power

A. Kathryn Power will leave the top post of the Rhode Island Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH) April 9, about thirteen months after she was tapped by former Governor Gina Raimondo to stabilize an agency mired in the problems of the Eleanor Slater Hospital.

Her resignation comes in the middle of a controversy involving the Eleanor Slater Hospital and at a critical time in the implementation of a 2014 civil rights consent decree affecting adults with developmental disabilities. .

In a letter submitted to Gov. Daniel McKee March 28, Power attributed her resignation to a family member’s “recently diagnosed health issues.”

Power’s letter was released by McKee’s office April 5.

In a statement, a spokesman for the governor said, “BHDDH has a critical mission and it will be a priority for the McKee Administration to find a candidate to live up to its values providing high quality care and services for some of Rhode Island’s most vulnerable residents.

“We thank Director Power for her service on the state and federal level and wish her all the best,” the spokesman said in a statement.

In her letter of resignation, Power said she believed she helped “move the organization in the right direction to embrace a more aligned set of programs and services that are highly reflective of the least restricted environment, the most appropriate level of clinical care, and the strong themes of personal choice, a safe, stable living situation, and whole life self-management.”

The controversy at Eleanor Slater Hospital, which Power inherited from a previous administration, started out as a billing issue involving the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services that left the state liable for tens of millions of dollars for patients deemed ineligible for federal reimbursement.

The bureaucratic matter has escalated as BHDDH has discharged some Eleanor Slater Hospital patients into what mental health advocates allege are unsafe situations with inadequate safety nets.

Power has more than 30 years’ experience in the mental health field, including a decade-long tenure as the director of BHDDH, from 1993 to 2003, when she left to join the federal government.

She is a former region one administrator for the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).

Power said that, just as in her previous tenure at BHDDH, “my priority has been, first and foremost, the well-being and sensitive care of individuals with behavioral health conditions, intellectual/developmental disabilities, and hospital patients.”

In offhand remarks shortly after former Governor Raimondo nominated her to return to BHDDH as second time, Power indicated she had not sought the post but wished to respond to the governor’s call.

BHDDH is entering a critical period of change to services for adults with developmental disabilities as it prepares to comply during the next three years to a 2014 federal civil rights consent decree that calls for the integration of those with intellectual challenges in their communities.

$15 M for RI DD Reform Planned In Next Budget

By Gina Macris

Rhode Island Governor Daniel McKee unveiled a budget plan March 11 that includes $15 million for structural reforms to services for adults with developmental disabilities in the next fiscal year.

Overall, McKee’s has proposed an $11.17 billion budget for Fiscal 2022 which promises to resolve a statewide $336 million deficit while protecting those hardest-hit by the pandemic and helping small business. McKee said the budget “protects Rhode Islanders through an unprecedented public health crisis and lays the foundation for a durable recovery.”

At a noontime virtual briefing for reporters, A. Kathryn Power, director of the state Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities, and Hospitals, said $10 million of the developmental disabilities reform effort will come from state revenue and another $5 million will be funded by the federal government.

She said BHDDH wants to create a “stronger provider community that is fiscally sustainable.” The reform efforts will increase opportunities for employment and other services for adults with developmental disabilities, she said.

Chief Judge John J. MCConnell, Jr. of the U.S. District Court has ordered the state to develop a three-year plan for overhauling privately-run services comply with a 21014 consent decree which requires Rhode Island to integrate adults with developmental disabilities in their communities in accordance with the Americans With Disabilities Act.

The developmental disabilities budget contains a separate $4.5 million allocation for “alternative placements” for adults with developmental disabilities who live in a state-run group home system called Rhode Island Community Living and Supports.

A ten-percent increase for shared living caregivers also will be in the budget, as part of another group of expenditures intended to encourage more home and community-based services as an alternative to residential care.

Additional information was not immediately available on budget details affecting those with developmental disabilities.

Hospitals Allegedly Violate RI DOH Visitation Policy For Patients With Disabilities

By Gina Macris

Family members of people with developmental disabilities reportedly are being barred from visiting hospitalized patients despite a revised Rhode Island state policy that allows essential support persons to help facilitate their care.

Both Disability Rights Rhode Island (DRRI) and the state Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH) have received complaints that hospitals are preventing caregivers from seeing patients with disabilities.

DRRI is seeking additional feedback from the community on how the policy is being implemented when those with intellectual or developmental disabilities are hospitalized, by phone at 401-831-3150 or by email at contact@drri.org.

The alleged hospital policy violations come in the face of apparent improving health statistics, which indicate that no deaths of residents of group homes for adult s with developmental disabilities have been reported for nearly three weeks.

Still, families of persons with intellectual and developmental challenges have complained that hospitals are barring them from visiting loved ones, contrary to a Department of Health policy adopted in early May that says essential support persons can accompany patients with disabilities to facilitate communication, equal access to treatment and the provision of informed consent.

In one particular case, Kevin Savage, the Director of the Division of Developmental Disabilities, contacted hospital “risk management” officials, who agreed to help, according to a BHDDH spokesman. The spokesman said the situation still was still not resolved to the family’s satisfaction.

In addition, the BHDDH director, A. Kathryn Power, contacted Dr. Nicole Alexander-Scott, director of the Department of Health. She, in turn, “reached out to all hospital CEOs to reinforce the RIDOH guidance in order to reiterate the rights of people with I/DD,” according to the BHDDH spokesman.

DRRI’s counterpart in Connecticut, along with other statewide and national advocacy organizations, had tried since April to persuade that state’s public health officials to allow support persons to help hospitalized patients with disabilities, but ended up filing a formal discrimination complaint with the Office of Civil Rights of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services on behalf of three patients in separate hospitals.

That complaint was settled with a change in Connecticut’s hospital visitation policy, announced by Disability Rights Connecticut on June 9.

In Rhode Island, a total of 158 people living in group homes for adults with developmental disabilities have tested positive for COVID-19. The total includes 10 persons who have died, with the most recent death reported June 2, according to BHDDH spokespersons.

On a related front, a federal judge is seeking guidance from an independent monitor on ways community-based integrated services should change in light of the coronavirus. Daytime services have all but stopped since the pandemic hit Rhode Island in March, and the state has not yet adopted a formal plan for them to resume on a large scale.

The U.S. District Court and the U.S. Department of Justice have jurisdiction over the state’s daytime services under a 2014 consent decree intended to correct Rhode Island’s segregation of adults with developmental disabilities, a violation of the Americans With Disabilities Act.

Chief Judge John J. McConnell, Jr. has recently ordered the independent court monitor in the case to prepare a report by the end of the month on how to approach community-based integrated services in light of the lingering health and safety concerns posed by COVID-19. 

The monitor, A. Anthony Antosh, is expected to submit the report by the end of June. McConnell has scheduled a court hearing on the consent decree July 30 at 2 p.m. The hearing will be accessible to the public by telephone and through the internet’s Zoom service.

New RI BHDDH Director Cancels Plan For "Health Home" Case Management Model

By Gina Macris

This article has been corrected and updated.

A costly and controversial proposal for privatizing the management of individualized services for adults with developmental disabilities in Rhode Island has been axed by the new director of the Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH).

The director, A. Kathryn Power, acted out of concern that the state would face a “financial cliff” after an initial start-up period almost entirely funded by the federal Medicaid program, according to a BHDDH spokesman.

The managed care initiative, which Medicaid has labeled a Health Home, would have created a third-party entity to plan, coordinate and monitor services on a person-by-person basis.

“Director Power was concerned whether the Health Homes initiative represented the right direction for consumers and families, as well as the Department, given the temporary nature of the federal funding,” said the spokesman, Randal Edgar.

The Medicaid program offers 90 percent federal funding Health Homes for two years, but after that, the state would be responsible for nearly half the cost of maintaining the Health Home. On Feb. 28, a BHDDH spokesman said that long-term, the Health Home would have cost the state about $5 million a year.

Throughout the past year, the Division of Developmental Disabilities “conducted extensive stakeholder engagement around the design” of a Health Home for adults with intellectual or developmental disabilities, the spokesman said. “The scope and the projected enrollments were then used to guide the proposed rate methodology and cost analysis,” resulting in future costs estimated at about $5 million, the spokesman said. (It was incorrectly stated in an earlier version of this article that BHDDH had not calculated the long-term dollar amount that the state would have borne before Power cancelled the plans for a Health Home application.)

Power had been aware of community opposition to the Health Home idea. That factor, “coupled with her own experience of looking at the integrated health home model, led her to question the viability of this initiative,” Edgar said. Power returned to BHDDH after about 15 years in the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).

She said BHDDH will continue to pursue a case management model to satisfy a Medicaid rule that states eliminate conflicts of interest in three functions:

• funding

• delivery of services

• case-management; the planning,coordination, and oversight of supports.

Currently the state controls a critical element of the planning phase, an assessment called the Supports Intensity Scale (SIS.). The score from the SIS is fed into a secret algorithm that determines funding for a particular person,

The SIS was designed by the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities to assist planners in compiling a program of services meeting the needs and preferences of particular individuals, an approach compatible with the Integration Mandate of the Americans With Disabilities Act. The Mandate, reinforced by the Olmstead decision of the U.S. Supreme Court, says that individuals with disabilities have the right to services and supports they need to live, work, and play in their communities.

Using the SIS to determine individual appropriations resulted in a cookie –cutter approach that incentivized a system of sheltered workshops and day care centers when it was begun in 2011 as a key feature of Project Sustainability, a fee-for-service reimbursement system for privately-run developmental disability services.

Two years later, the operations of one of those workshops attracted a civil rights investigation from the U.S. Department of Justice that has led to federal oversight of the developmental disability service system until 2024. The key goal: to correct violations of the ADA’s integration mandate.

The Health Home proposal would not have touched the link between funding and the SIS, which was singled out for criticism by the DOJ in 2014 findings that led to a statewide consent decree.

Opposition to Health Homes has come from the special legislative commission which recently concluded a study of Project Sustainability, the Developmental Disability Council, the Community Provider Network of Rhode Island, and many families also have raised concerns about the Health Home.

In general, the critics have said a Health Home would have created an expensive and unnecessary bureaucracy at the same time that the services themselves are underfunded. .

The wages of direct care workers and related staff remain below the levels offered by Connecticut and Massachusetts for the same work, generating high turnover. The agencies employing the workers teeter on the edge of solvency, according to a recently released report compiled by BHDDH consultants. Families who manage a loved one’s program themselves also have had trouble finding staff.

A. Kathryn Power To Lead RI BHDDH

A. Kathryn Power

Rhode Island Governor Gina Raimondo and her Health and Human Services Secretary have tapped A. Kathryn Power, a veteran administrator of mental and behavioral health initiatives at both the state and federal level, to direct the Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH) – for the second time.

Power led the agency formerly known as the Department of Mental Health, Retardation and Hospitals during the administrations of former governors Bruce Sundlun and Lincoln Almond, from 1993 to 2003.

Known as a staunch consumer and family advocate wherever she has gone, Power left state government to become director of the federal Center for Mental Health Services, a part of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).

In the last 15 years, she also has served as SAMHSA’s Region One director, providing authoritative advice and assistance on behavioral health policies and innovations to inform the financing and delivery of prevention, treatment, and recovery services.

Raimondo said she was “thrilled that (Power) has agreed to once again assume leadership of BHDDH and I look forward to continuing to work together as we improve outcomes for all Rhode Islanders who live with behavioral health challenges and developmental disabilities.”

“Rhode Island is fortunate to have someone of Kathryn’s stature – possessing such a high level of expertise in behavioral healthcare and developmental disabilities – stepping into this vital position,” said Womazetta Jones, Secretary of the Executive Office of Health and Human Services.

Power said in a statement, “I’m thankful to Governor Raimondo and Secretary Jones for the opportunity to contribute to our state’s evolving system of care for individuals facing behavioral health conditions and developmental disabilities.”

“Our state has made significant progress over the last few decades, but we have more work to do to ensure that all Rhode Islanders have access to the care and support they need on their paths toward recovery and community integration.”

As BHDDH director, Power will oversee a troubled hospital system, developmental disability services in the midst of a ten-year overhaul under federal oversight, and behavioral healthcare issues that include the state’s response to the opioid crisis that permeates communities nationwide.

Power succeeds Rebecca Boss, who is stepping down Dec. 31.

Except for her fifteen years in the federal government, Power has worked in the mental health field in Rhode Island for most of her life.

In addition to having served once as director of BHDDH, she is a former director of the Rhode Island Office of Substance Abuse, the Governor’s Drug Program, and the Rhode Island Anti-Drug Coalition. From l985 to l990, Power served as Executive Director of the Rhode Island Council of Community Mental Health Centers.

She has served as President of the National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors and has received many awards for her work in mental health, substance abuse and civic leadership, as well as recognition for her advocacy on behalf of people with disabilities.

Power received her bachelor’s degree in education from St. Joseph’s College in Maryland, and her master’s degree in education and counseling from Western Maryland College. She is a graduate of the Toll Fellowship program in leadership training of the Council of State.Governments and another program in senior executive leadership at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government. Power is also a retired Captain in the U.S. Navy Reserve.